Joint Open Letter to the High Commissioner for Human Rights calling for a Fact-Finding Mission in Afghanistan

1 Jul, 2021 | Press Releases

Michelle Bachelet

High Commissioner for Human Rights Palais Wilson – United Nations Geneva, Switzerland

Joint Open Letter to the High Commissioner for Human Rights

Re: Support for the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission Call for a Fact- Finding Mission in Afghanistan

Your Excellency,

The undersigned organisations welcome the call you made to the Human Rights Council on June 21, 2021, to consider “mechanisms for an effective prevention response” to the rapidly deteriorating situation in Afghanistan. We are writing to urge you to take action to support the establishment of a United Nations-mandated Fact-Finding Mission in Afghanistan, as requested by the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission (AIHRC).

As you know, on June 8, 2021, insurgents carried out an attack on civilian deminers working for the Halo Trust in Baghlan province, with reports that the attackers were seeking out members of the Hazara Shia community. This followed the May 8, 2021 massacre of schoolgirls as they were leaving the premises of Sayed-Ul-Shuhada school in Dasht-e Barchi precinct of Kabul, a predominantly Hazara-Shia neighbourhood. These horrific attacks came after other attacks on civilians including a suicide bombing at Kabul University that killed at least 19 people, mostly students, and injured 22 others in November 2020; an attack at a maternity hospital in Dasht-e Barchi in May 2020 which killed 24 civilians including 11 mothers and a midwife, while newborns and other patients and staff were injured; and the attack on a Sikh temple in March 2020 that killed 26 civilians and injured 11 others. In addition, since September 2020 there has been an increased targeting of human rights defenders, women rights defenders, and journalists.

These atrocities have prompted the AIHRC to request an international fact-finding mission to look at attacks on Hazaras and other religious minorities, attacks on women and girls, and targeted killings of human rights defenders and other civilians since January 2020. According to the AIHRC’s call, the fact-finding mission should also investigate attacks against girls’ education and against healthcare centers in Afghanistan. The AIHRC says that the scale and nature of these attacks is beyond the capacity of the government, AIHRC or the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA) to investigate.

We agree with the AIHRC position that a Fact-Finding Mission should be set up to do the following:

  • Investigate and establish the facts and circumstances regarding the alarming increase in attacks targeting civilians since January 2020, and the underlying patterns of abuse, such as systematic discrimination, including targeting of the Hazara-Shia and the Sikh communities and repression based on gender, that amount to violations and abuses of international human rights law and international humanitarian law;
  • Collect, consolidate and analyze evidence and documentation and review alleged violations and abuses of international human rights law and international humanitarian law by all parties;
  • Identify, where possible, those responsible, with a view to ensuring that the perpetrators of violations are held accountable;
  • Secure an effective and coordinated response by the national authorities and the international community, in close cooperation with OHCHR/UNAMA and the AIHRC, to ensure accountability and deter any further targeted violence against civilians in particular ethnic and religious minorities;
  • Make recommendations, in particular on accountability measures, with a view to avoiding and ending impunity and ensuring legal accountability, including individual criminal liability;
  • Make recommendations for improving access to justice and obtaining reparations for victims and survivors.
  • To help bring an end to the cycle of violence and impunity against civilians in Afghanistan and establish a measure of accountability, we urge you to continue to actively support the creation of this urgently needed mandate by the UN Human Rights Council.
  • Please accept the assurances of our highest consideration. Sincerely,

Mary Akrami

Executive Director, Afghan Women’s Network

Sayed Hussain Anosh

Executive Director, Civil Society and Human Rights Network (CSHRN)

Federico Borello

Executive Director, Center for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC)

Agnès Callamard 

Secretary General, Amnesty International

Charles Davy 

Managing Director, Afghanaid

Samiullah Hamidee

Director, Organisation for Social and Economic Development (OSED)

Guissou Jahangiri 

Executive Director, Armanshahr/OPEN ASIA

Hadi Marifat

Executive Director, Afghanistan Human Rights and Democracy Organization

Alice Mogwe

President, FIDH/International Federation for Human Rights

Horia Mosadiq

Executive Director, Safety and Mitigation Risk Organization

Suraya Pakzad

Executive Director, Voice of Women Organization (VWO)

Ehsan Qaane

Co-Founder and Member, Transitional Justice Coordination Group (TJCG)

Aziz Rafiee

Executive Director, Afghanistan Civil Society Forum-Organization

Aziz Rafiee

Chairperson, Afghanistan Human Rights Defenders Committee

Kenneth Roth 

Executive Director, Human Rights Watch

Mahbouba Seraj

Executive Director, Afghan Women Skills Development Center

Mohammad Shafaq

Executive Director, Afghanistan Young Greens (AYG)

Niccolò Figá Talamanca 

Secretary General, No Peace Without Justice

Elizabeth Winter

Executive Director, British and Irish Agencies Afghanistan Group (BAAG)